Shingle Damage That Requires Replacement | Big Easy Roof Contractors FREE Roofing Estimates
damaged asphalt shingles

Types of Shingle Damage That Require Replacement

Shingle damage is quite self-explanatory. It refers to the wear and tear on the shingle structure over time.

The damage can include anything from minor cracking to severe granule loss or even complete loss of the shingle. Shingles are a significant part of the roofing structure as they provide insulation and protection from various weather elements.

Multiple types of shingles are used in homes; the most common ones are asphalt shingles, wood shingles, and tile shingles. Each has certain unique advantages and disadvantages, and thus, they present specific kinds of damage over time.

For instance, asphalt shingles might experience granule loss and curling, while wood shingles are prone to splitting and warping over time.

Identifying shingle damage isn’t very difficult; even so, it remains ignored by several homeowners due to the unavailability of time or skills.

Some typical indicators of shingle damage are leaking roofs, higher energy bills because of poor insulation, and visible signs on the shingle structure itself such as dark spots or curled edges.

Causes of Shingle Damage

Like anything exposed to the environment, Shingles, too, are subject to wear and tear due to various factors. The most common cause of shingle damage is weather.

Shingles can bear heavy rain, winds, and hail, but severe weather conditions will likely lead to some degree of shingle damage. High winds can blow off the shingles, while hailstones can cause breaking or cracking of the shingles.

Secondly, improper installation is another dominant cause of shingle damage. If not installed correctly, the shingles can start leaning off, causing severe damage. Biological factors such as mold, algae, or lichen can also cause damage by breaking down the shingle material. Lastly, poor attic ventilation can lead to heat buildup, causing shingle damage from below.

Effects of Ignoring Shingle Damage

As mentioned earlier, shingles play a crucial role in the overall structure of the house. Therefore, ignoring shingle damage can lead to several consequences. The most immediate effect can be seen in your energy bills.

Damage to the shingles can lead to poor insulation, resulting in higher energy costs. Over time, damaged shingles can also lead to structural damage as the roof’s underlayment might get exposed to weather elements.

Also, damaged shingles can lead to moisture seeping into the house. This can create conditions favorable to mold and mildew growth, which are hazardous to health. In extreme cases of damage and negligence, the entire roofing structure might collapse, putting the safety of the residents at risk.

Therefore, regular inspection and timely repair of shingle damage should be a priority for homeowners for maintaining the overall safety and structural integrity of the house.

Types of Shingle Damages that Require Replacement

Shingle roofs are a popular roofing option because of their durability. However, over time, they can succumb to damage due to various factors, such as inclement weather, old age, or poor installation.

Cracked or Broken Shingles

One common type of shingle damage is cracking or breaking. This typically happens due to the impact from falling tree limbs or hailstones or due to normal wear and tear.

Cracked or broken shingles can allow water to seep through, causing leaks and water damage to the structure below. It’s essential to replace these damaged shingled immediately to prevent further deterioration.

Missing Shingles

Another type of damage that necessitates shingle replacement is when shingles are missing. Strong winds are often the culprit, ripping shingles from the roof deck.

Missing shingles expose the underlying materials to the elements, leading to severe water damage if not addressed promptly. A roofing professional can conduct a roof inspection to identify any missing shingles and replace them efficiently.

Curled or Cupped Shingles

Curled or cupped shingles are usually a sign of aging or prolonged exposure to heat. The shingle corners lift, creating a cup-like appearance that can hold water or snow.

As a result, they can cause leaks and water damage when they can’t effectively shed water. Replacing curled or cupped shingles is crucial to maintaining the functionality of your roof.

Bald or Balding Shingles

Shingles that are bald or balding are stripped of their protective layer of granules. This loss can result from weather aspects such as rain and wind or even foot traffic on the roof. Without these granules, the shingles are left vulnerable to the impact of UV rays, which can hasten aging and ultimately damage your roof. Replacing bald shingles is essential in maintaining the lifespan of your roof.

Buckling Shingles

Buckling shingles have a warped appearance and are typically caused by moisture in the attic or improperly installed underlayment.

They’re not just an eyesore; they’re a risk factor for leaks. Because buckling can be caused by underlying issues, it’s essential to have a roofing contractor inspect your roof and replace any buckling shingles.

Blistered Shingles

Blistered shingles appear as bubbles or blisters on the surface due to intense heat and poor ventilation.

These blisters can eventually burst, exposing the asphalt layers underneath to the sun, rain, and other elements. If not remedied, blistered shingles can lead to leaks and other structural damage. Regular inspections can help catch blistering early for immediate replacement.

Rotting Shingles

Rotting shingles are a sign of a serious problem. This usually happens when the mat at the core of the shingle absorbs moisture. When this occurs, the shingles can degrade and cause substantial roof damage.

rotting shingles

The presence of rotting shingles indicates a severe problem that requires immediate attention, including inspection and complete roof replacement if necessary.

In dealing with any of these shingle damages, ensure to work with a certified and experienced roofing professional. Timely shingle replacement can save you money in the long run and increase the lifespan of your roof.

Assessing shingle damage is a crucial aspect of maintaining the integrity of your house. When shingles on your roof are damaged, it leads to water leaks, which can lead to substantial damage inside your home.

Shingles are shields for your house’s roof and they also add aesthetic appeal to your dwelling. However, regular damage, weather conditions, or simply time can wear off these shingles. Serious damage can often lead to the replacement of the entire roof.

Identifying Signs of Shingle Damage

Shingle damage can be characterized by various signs that you can easily spot. The primary signs of shingle damage include cracked or curling shingles, missing shingles, or spots where the shingles’ granules have worn off.

If you notice areas where shingles are missing, it is highly possible that the other places are also weak and hence need to be looked at.

Moreover, look out for signs of water leakage inside your home. This might indicate that your roof is no longer in a position to resist water and needs either a repair or replacement. Other signs of possible shingle damage are dark and dirty spots on the shingles.

They might occur from outside debris accumulations or, worse, due to the shingles’ granules wearing off.

Inspection and Assessment Process for Shingle Damage

To inspect and assess the damage to the shingles on your roof, start by setting a specific day aside for the assessment. Choose a day when you expect the weather to be calm; not too windy or rainy. A safe roof is very much important for a thorough inspection.

The task involves gauging the rate of external damage and then analyzing if it has led to more significant problems for the upper story, such as leaks or water damage. Climbing a ladder to access the roof should be done carefully and it is recommended to have all the required safety gear.

You need to visually inspect all the shingles from the ridge vent down to the eaves. Look for missing, curling, or cracking shingles. Look out for the dark spots on the shingles. Also, check if the shingles’ granules might have worn off.

Keep in mind that all shingles have a certain life span after which they will need to be replaced. So consider this factor too while assessing the severity of the damage.

When to Involve a Professional

While some people might be comfortable performing these inspections on their own, it’s always safer and recommended to involve a professional. Shingles can be slippery, and it’s possible to overlook damage, especially if you’re not clear on what to look for.

Roofing professionals possess the necessary tools, safety equipment, and knowledge required to assess the extent of shingle damage. A professional will be able to spot the signs of damage more accurately and also provide suggestions for the best course of action to undertake, whether it involves repair or replacement of the damaged shingles.

If you suspect damage but cannot clearly identify it, schedule an inspection with a trained roofing professional.

Repair vs. Replacement of Damaged Shingles

When faced with damaged shingles, homeowners are often torn between the decision to repair or replace them altogether.

The decision is typically dictated by numerous factors, ranging from the financial commitment to the extent of the damage.

Comparing Costs

Generally, repairing damaged shingles is less expensive upfront. However, this solution is not always cost-effective in the long run, particularly if the shingles continually require repair. Repair costs primarily consist of the labor fee and the cost of materials. These costs can add up over time, especially when constant repairs are needed.

On the contrary, replacing shingles is more costly upfront. This is due to the extent of work involved, which often entails replacing the entire roofing structure. Despite these high initial costs, considering this option can be economical in the long run.

Typically, replacement offers a long-term solution, effectively eliminating the need for continual repairs.

Considering the Extent of Damage

Minor damage often calls for simple repairs. This includes slight curling, granule loss, or small punctures. In such cases, it’s usually unnecessary to replace the entire roof, as skilled contractors can easily restore the damaged shingles to their prime condition.

However, when the damage extends to a large section of the roof or affects the roofing structure, replacement becomes a more feasible option. Extensive damage typically includes severe curling, warping, deep cracks, or missing shingles.

Such cases dictate a need for replacement, as the structural integrity of the roof is compromised and repairing such an area could lead to more issues in the future.

Long-term Implications

Consideration of the long-term implications of either option is essential. Given the nature of repairs, which typically address the problem on a surface level, there’s a good chance the issues may recur.

For instance, if your roof often loses shingles due to high winds, choosing to repair each time might just be treating the symptom and not the root cause. Repeated repairs can introduce a cycle of short-lived solutions, requiring frequent attention.

Otherwise, replacement offers a long-term solution. A replaced shingle roof can last up to 20 years with adequate maintenance. In essence, while you might shell out more money upfront, the long-term benefits should outweigh the initial cost.

Plus, a new roof can even increase the value of your home, which is a perk if you’re thinking about selling in the near future.

Dealing with Shingle Replacement

Shingle replacement is an essential aspect of maintaining the overall structural integrity of your home, particularly your roof.

Replacing your roof shingles is significant not just aesthetically, but also functionally as it provides protection against the external elements—rain, wind, heat, and snow.

Selecting a Roofing Contractor for Shingle Replacement

Choosing an experienced roofing contractor for your shingle replacement project is crucial. You’ll want someone reputable, reliable, and experienced in handling various types of shingles.

It’s recommended to perform a thorough background check on your prospective contractor.

Check for customer reviews and references, see if they have the necessary licenses and permits, and whether they offer warranties on their work. It’s also advisable to compare costs and services provided by different contractors before making a decision.

Considerations for Shingle Replacement

When it comes to shingle replacement, it’s vital to select the correct type of shingles that suit your needs and aesthetic preferences. Shingles come in a variety of materials, including asphalt, tile, wood, slate, and metal.

Each material has its pros and cons, so it’s necessary to consider factors such as your region’s climate, your home’s architectural style, and the cost when selecting shingles. Similarly, the color and style of the shingles can significantly impact the overall look of your home.

Consider colors and designs that complement the exterior of your house for an attractive finish.

Steps in the Shingle Replacement Process

Shingle replacement is a straightforward process that typically involves the following steps:

  • Removing old shingles,
  • Preparing the roof surface,
  • Installing underlayment,
  • Applying new shingles, and
  • Cleaning up the worksite.

Whether you choose to do it yourself or hire professionals, it’s important to follow the correct installation procedures and safety protocols. Keep in mind that shingle replacement can be a labor-intensive and time-consuming task, so plan accordingly.

Understanding Shingle Warranties


A shingle warranty is an agreement between the consumer and the manufacturer or contractor, guaranteeing the quality of the roofing shingles and covering any defects that may occur in a specified period.

What a Shingle Warranty Covers

Shingle warranties typically cover any manufacturing defects and workmanship flaws.

They assure that the shingles are fit for the intended purpose, free of defects, and will perform as promised under normal use.

If any issues occur within the warranty period, the manufacturer or contractor agrees to replace or repair the defective shingles at no cost.

Limitations and Exclusions in Shingle Warranties

While shingle warranties offer substantial protection, they come with certain limitations and exclusions.

For instance, they may not cover damage caused by improper installation, abnormal weather conditions, or neglect of regular maintenance.

Therefore, it’s essential to read and understand the warranty’s fine print before proceeding.

How to Make a Claim on a Shingle Warranty

Making a claim on a shingle warranty involves:

  • Contacting the manufacturer or contractor,
  • Providing proof of purchase, and
  • Explaining the nature of the problem.

They may send an inspector for an assessment, and if the claim is validated, they will arrange for the necessary repairs or replacement. It’s important to retain all relevant documents (purchase invoices, warranties, etc.) and address the issues as soon as you identify them, to make the claim process smoother.

Final Word

Shingle replacement or repair is a crucial decision and should not be taken lightly. The right choice will depend on multiple factors, such as the nature of the damage, cost, and long-term implications.

If you’re considering shingle replacement or repair for your roof, get in touch with Big Easy Roof Contractors. We specialize in roofing services and provide high-quality workmanship at competitive rates.

Our experienced team of professionals is well-versed in various types of shingle replacement and repair projects and can help you select the best option to suit your needs.

We also offer a variety of shingle warranties, so you can be assured that your roof is in safe hands. Contact us today and get a free quote for your project!

Related Posts